Hi Rahul, Thank you for taking the time to upload your work. We apologize for the delay in getting your feedback posted. First, we want to recognize the hierarchy you created because you have done an excellent job of using different weights and sizes for each section to show importance. I would consider adding some type of title to the area that shows "Invested/limit" looking at this I am not sure if it's a limit set by the user or by the app itself. If it's user-generated maybe making an easy way to adjust that may increase the amount of money users put into your app/company. Overall I think you have done a good job using colors that match the seriousness of the product you designed and have used appropriate space to break up sections. I hope this feedback is helpful!

Wow thank you for the feedback. Definitely will be a learning for me! Thank you so much, really appreciate it!

Hi Radiva, Thank you for uploading your work. I see you used one of our past challenge prompts which I love. One thing about the experience that I think may confuse users is that you have "Add to cart" and when it's clicked it shows which persons cart to add it to. People may come into the app and be looking for that option and think it doesn't exist. I would consider possibly adding a dropdown combo button to the add cart so people could expand the button to pick the person's cart. Visually I think the top screens all look clean. I would consider the contrast of the description text since it looks a bit light in color. I would also consider exploring illustrations/graphics for the bottom 3 screens that are more consistent with the rest of your app. Right now it seems like two different products in my opinion. I hope this feedback helps!

@crowwwn and @amanjindal thanks for the feedback , I will surely update my design as per your feedback :)

Hi Priyansh, thank you for uploading your work. I like that you have a consistent color palette throughout each page, it helps build brand recognition so users know what site they are looking at. I would consider using a lighter grey for the background since this shade may reduce the contrast of some of the text making it hard to read. For the first 4 screens, you have done an excellent job mixing text and other visuals to keep the page exciting. There is a lot of text on the far right page that most users probably won't read. I would consider how you could take that page and make it more visual so users aren't stuck reading each paragraph. I hope this feedback is helpful, thank you again for uploading your work!

Design is good but landing page should have more clear message I think. Also, if UX design course is a page which is redirected from courses then it should be highlighted and it should contain bread crumbs.

First of Thank you for your valuable Feedback. I have made some more screen designs of the same which shows different different sections and other functionalities. But I will add your suggestion as well, thank you once again.

Hi Rituraj! Thank you for uploading your work :) Your design looks great, you have used a modern layout and used color to call attention to the essential areas of the design. I would consider giving a bit more detail under "Practice Platform" as I am not sure if clicking that will give me lessons or if it's going to redirect me to a different website/blog. It also looks like the primary navigation button at the bottom is for metrics which I am not sure deserves that much attention. I would consider the primary job users try to do and make that the primary button. Overall great work, I hope this feedback is helpful!

Thank you sir

Kritika, you have done a fantastic job selecting images that help make your design look high quality. You have also done a good job making a clear hierarchy on each page. I would consider adding labels to the X and Y axis of the My Progress chart so users understand what is being tracked. I would also consider looking for a bit more inspiration before starting your design, it may help you stay consistent with user expectations.

Hey Anna! liked that the user has multiple actions he can do after clicking on plus. I liked the bundle feature, it's more like wishlist groups, which now can be shared with friends so they can select whatever they want. However, these are a few ways I feel the design can be improved- -I understand that you tried to give the app a "holiday season" feel to it with a custom background, but I feel that it is trying to fight for my attention which in the first place should be on the content of the app. -Text sizes are too small across the whole design. Try to bump them to 14px and see how significantly legibility improves. -Since the "plus" icon on the cards is the primary for the user, I feel there is not enough touch area to be able to be clicked on it easily. Try to redesign the cards. -Although it is not a hard and fast rule, but if bundle button is the main CTA, keep it on the right side of the screen for better reach. -The bundle list looks very cluttered, can be improved. The tray's padding on the top can be made the same as of the bottom. -In the bottom nav, the active/ inactive states is not so clearly visible to me. Try to make all the icons & labels of the inactive states grey so it can be differentiated the most. -On the 4th screen, since the share button is the main action on the screen, it can be made more prominent which can give the user a sense of direction for the follow. Rest of the flow is fine. However I would have loved to see the flow when the other person opens the link to select what gift he/ she wants. Great attempt. Good luck

Hi, Anna I have feedback for you, If I have to send multiple gift options to someone how can I send also what about if I have to select multiple gif options from which one has sent me that entire flow is missing? please go through the problem statement once and try to design the solution as our goal, The text on your design is not clearly visible to me first of all and is difficult to interpret, Experiment with font sizes and colors. make them large and visible so that one can at least read them.

@vaishnavihire thank you for the feedback, this is something we will work on improving.

About the feedback, I received on my work I have clearly added options to select and send multiple gifts by the sender and also the option to select a gift from the receiver side- if you consider the wishlist screen, and also the related prototyping. If you open the left panel from the Figma link, the flow is clearly named there. The reason I added categorization for the wishlist is - if one had already sent an option to "sister 1" and later if he wants to send an option to "sister 2", one can simply assign the same to different relations if they have somewhat the same wishes/choices, rather than again searching for new gift items so categorization is done with that intent. So obviously this has been done with specific intent. @crowwwn @barker I am sorry I have to tag you. I have been asked to critically evaluate my own solution, though we have a feedback option with an intent to help and bridge the flaws so that one can further improve. I can see many of the contestants have received constructive feedback and efforts involved in explaining, but my one was least sensible even on the second attempt.

Hi Vaishnavi! Unnecessary features like creating categories in the wishlist just don't add up to the problem statement (it just complicates the whole process for the user) I don't know how else I can convey that your presentation is not up to the mark. If you'll critically evaluate your own work then maybe you can understand the issues. Also, before sharing the prototype make sure it works properly and the user flow is up to the mark! Although you've done a terrific job overall within the given time frame. Kudos

@aviralverma I could not understand your feedback. Not that constructive enough for me. What unnecessary things, other than the problem statements, have you found in this solution? can you elaborate? I am adding here a prototyping link help to understand the flow better https://www.figma.com/proto/SeSe1B1GRKPcRCkPnjFxr6/Holiday-Shopping?page-id=0%3A1&node-id=1%3A267&viewport=728%2C487%2C0.22&scaling=scale-down&starting-point-node-id=1%3A267&show-proto-sidebar=1

There are just so many unnecessary screen and information! The most important thing i.e. the user path that shows how someone will pick the gifts that are sent to them looks incomplete (or not presented properly) The design presentation is very difficult to comprehend and your solution is a bit complicated. However, you did a fantastic job in mantaining consistency and visual hierarchy!

Hi, - The color scheme you have chosen is black and entire UI has blocked square with light black background. Though you could have tried with some lighter color scheme. - When I look at the app, its not actually looks like a gift app, but giving me a fell of ecommerce app. I don't know why you have added name "fantacy" for the app, not going with the theme. - Login screen you have given too many options for login, you could have added given a mobile number. The info icon over image doesn't seems appropriate on image, affects the visibility. - You have named it as an exchange, what if some one just want to give gifts? and doesn't want any exchange, I mean the idea is good! but not going with the entire goal of problem to be resolved -Heading you have mentioned shop and at left you have text USA, what does that text indicate? Dashboard, has current and previous, what does that current and previous indicate?. Wish of the week, is not something adding meaning and is repetitive, you could have name as "Wishes for and person name" - Below search on "Shop" screen you have text write in a wish? its that simple text with heading, or an CTA? Color pallet and related component consistency can be improve. -.Create an exchange screen, the form below, placeholder text, "Name your exchange", "When it is happening" and when the sign up deadline.. is diluting the entire focus on goal of the problem. - Also exchanging gift is restricting user to return or except something in return, rather I would suggest you to keep this open like - whoever wants to send they can. - The idea and approach is different but if you could have added something relate to adding multiple gift items to Wishlist that would have added more in terms of problem statement! That's all from my side. Good luck

Hey, The color scheme you used is good. I would like to write some suggestions here. - Calling it "Exchange" just doesn't look right at all. Searching for a gift is a very happy experience for Users. Everyone likes the experience of searching for gifts and asking for ideas. "Exchange" - it could offend some users. - Well this is not related to the challenge but still, I would like to tell the name 'Fantasy' is also not relatable to the product. It's an eCommerce website so it can be like Giftfy, Giftcart or anything. - Your approach is pretty different you created a whole gifts exchange app. - Ui is amazing. keep it up ;)

Your Color Pallette's Consistency is Really Good.. But In the Exchange Creating Page, (Next)Button is a CTA, So You've to use Buttons with Borders and Colors... In the Shop Page (Add to Wishlist) button is small, not perfectly alligned and you forgot to use Capital Letters.. You can use USD or $ instead of US$

Hey Nisha, I would like to give you a few suggestions: Firstly I think you have not interpreted the brief completely. 1. There is no option to create list for sending multiple presents for your friends and family. 2. There is no way the receiver can receive present options and select gift for themselves. UI wise: 1. The background gradient is not good. Features on it are not coming out well. 2. The black colour that you have used is too dark in all the elements (fonts border around the cards, border around filter, icons etc), try to use lighter shades. 3. Try to build a font hierarchy for heading, sub heading and paragraph text. That will help segregate information according to the importance. Use same font type everywhere. 4. Add consistent left and right padding in all the screens. 5. There is no need to add logo on each screen, it takes up space which can be used to show important information. 6. In the bottom navigation bar, the icons look too dark and the line under the home is not very clear to indicate that it is selected. 7. Try to add a primary color to highlight key components. That will help user focus on important elements on the screen. Onboarding screen 1. Why is there option to scroll multiple banners on the home screen? 2. Fonts of skip icon is too small. Home screen 1. In filters you can make the edges around the box light grey and add some padding around the word. 2. In banners there are multiple dots, it is not clear which banner among the 5 banner is selected. 3. Add spacing under the heading "Recommended" to give it a cleaner look. 4. Under recommended product list add some details like product name, price etc. to give user some details about the product before they click to see details. Categories 1. Remove the border around the product. Increase space between card and text under it. Cart 1. Increase space between "address" and text box under it, similarly between "number" and text box under it. 2. Call icon needs to be flipped horizontally. 3. In order details "free size" and "quality" buttons looks disabled. 4. "Proceed to pay" can be a bigger button. Profile 1. Language can be moved down, it is too close to profile icon. 2. Mobile number and email address is too close to the profile icon. Try to increase space between them. 3. Icons sizes can be reduced a little bit. Refer material.io to design a proper design system that will help you design better UI. Try to create information architecture to create a proper user flow to cater to the brief properly.

Hey Rupal! You tried to come up with a solution and it's great. I would like to suggest few points here. - All icons in navigation are filled with black color which is hard to navigate you had put a line under the selected option(Icon) but it's still difficult to differentiate. instead of that, you can use line icons. - In the button drop shadow is too bright. - Background gradient is not much match with typography and it's difficult to skim through information. - Actionable tasks like proceed to pay and logout is in a neutral color (Black, White & Grey), and general information like trending and recommended is also in a neutral color but there should be different so instead of using neutral on the actionable task you could use primary color which is pink in this case. - Personal tip - instead of using a border on the image, Use Drop shadow with a good amount of blur and less opacity. - The main UX Challenge "I want to be able to select multiple present options, so my friends and family can pick the gift that best fits their needs." Remains Unsolved as I see there is no option of choosing multiple gifts. Keep up the good work : )