Search

Hi Hasan, When I have to send more than one gift to the sender how should I do that, as in your design I can't see that 1. When I open each item in detail mode I can just see the "add cart button" I mean how can you directly add a gift to the cart unless it's selected by someone? So that can be added to the wishlist, 2. A section with green background is seen above add to cart which says share your list and gift by choice, what does that mean? how can one share your list from the product detail view? 3. Also, green color is not consistently used for CTA's. 4. I am not able to trace the interaction flow for how one can send or receive multiple gift options.

@vaishnavihire thank you for the feedback, this is something we will work on improving.

About the feedback, I received on my work I have clearly added options to select and send multiple gifts by the sender and also the option to select a gift from the receiver side- if you consider the wishlist screen, and also the related prototyping. If you open the left panel from the Figma link, the flow is clearly named there. The reason I added categorization for the wishlist is - if one had already sent an option to "sister 1" and later if he wants to send an option to "sister 2", one can simply assign the same to different relations if they have somewhat the same wishes/choices, rather than again searching for new gift items so categorization is done with that intent. So obviously this has been done with specific intent. @crowwwn @barker I am sorry I have to tag you. I have been asked to critically evaluate my own solution, though we have a feedback option with an intent to help and bridge the flaws so that one can further improve. I can see many of the contestants have received constructive feedback and efforts involved in explaining, but my one was least sensible even on the second attempt.

Hi Vaishnavi! Unnecessary features like creating categories in the wishlist just don't add up to the problem statement (it just complicates the whole process for the user) I don't know how else I can convey that your presentation is not up to the mark. If you'll critically evaluate your own work then maybe you can understand the issues. Also, before sharing the prototype make sure it works properly and the user flow is up to the mark! Although you've done a terrific job overall within the given time frame. Kudos

@aviralverma I could not understand your feedback. Not that constructive enough for me. What unnecessary things, other than the problem statements, have you found in this solution? can you elaborate? I am adding here a prototyping link help to understand the flow better https://www.figma.com/proto/SeSe1B1GRKPcRCkPnjFxr6/Holiday-Shopping?page-id=0%3A1&node-id=1%3A267&viewport=728%2C487%2C0.22&scaling=scale-down&starting-point-node-id=1%3A267&show-proto-sidebar=1

There are just so many unnecessary screen and information! The most important thing i.e. the user path that shows how someone will pick the gifts that are sent to them looks incomplete (or not presented properly) The design presentation is very difficult to comprehend and your solution is a bit complicated. However, you did a fantastic job in mantaining consistency and visual hierarchy!

Hi, - The color scheme you have chosen is black and entire UI has blocked square with light black background. Though you could have tried with some lighter color scheme. - When I look at the app, its not actually looks like a gift app, but giving me a fell of ecommerce app. I don't know why you have added name "fantacy" for the app, not going with the theme. - Login screen you have given too many options for login, you could have added given a mobile number. The info icon over image doesn't seems appropriate on image, affects the visibility. - You have named it as an exchange, what if some one just want to give gifts? and doesn't want any exchange, I mean the idea is good! but not going with the entire goal of problem to be resolved -Heading you have mentioned shop and at left you have text USA, what does that text indicate? Dashboard, has current and previous, what does that current and previous indicate?. Wish of the week, is not something adding meaning and is repetitive, you could have name as "Wishes for and person name" - Below search on "Shop" screen you have text write in a wish? its that simple text with heading, or an CTA? Color pallet and related component consistency can be improve. -.Create an exchange screen, the form below, placeholder text, "Name your exchange", "When it is happening" and when the sign up deadline.. is diluting the entire focus on goal of the problem. - Also exchanging gift is restricting user to return or except something in return, rather I would suggest you to keep this open like - whoever wants to send they can. - The idea and approach is different but if you could have added something relate to adding multiple gift items to Wishlist that would have added more in terms of problem statement! That's all from my side. Good luck

Hey, The color scheme you used is good. I would like to write some suggestions here. - Calling it "Exchange" just doesn't look right at all. Searching for a gift is a very happy experience for Users. Everyone likes the experience of searching for gifts and asking for ideas. "Exchange" - it could offend some users. - Well this is not related to the challenge but still, I would like to tell the name 'Fantasy' is also not relatable to the product. It's an eCommerce website so it can be like Giftfy, Giftcart or anything. - Your approach is pretty different you created a whole gifts exchange app. - Ui is amazing. keep it up ;)

Your Color Pallette's Consistency is Really Good.. But In the Exchange Creating Page, (Next)Button is a CTA, So You've to use Buttons with Borders and Colors... In the Shop Page (Add to Wishlist) button is small, not perfectly alligned and you forgot to use Capital Letters.. You can use USD or $ instead of US$

Hey Vatsal! Really clean and functional stuff as usual. But these are a few things that concern me about this solution- 1. I am not sure why you used yellow boxes behind the country flag and name in the live score section. What purpose does it serve? I am worried about visibility of flags which have yellow or similar color in them. 2. In the cards of upcoming matches, why is "fifa world cup 2022" getting repeated in all the cards? The tournament name is quite clear since the app is dedicated for the world cup also the top side of the screen also mentions the tournament name. 3. The icons in the bottom nav look very similar. They all have a list sort of identity to it, making it very difficult to differentiate since they don't have any icon text label as well. 4. In the ticket's section, you have divided it on the basis of upcoming matches tickets and "booked". What exactly is booked, I am not so sure about it. Is it the past tickets that have been used? Why is it the primary selection then (left button)? As a user, I would be more inclined to know about my upcoming tickets (which have not been used) rather than the ones which are already used. 5. Lastly, the solution does not tell me where exactly I can stream the matches, so I guess you have missed on that part. Thank You & Good luck

Hi Core UX, I would to like provide a few suggestions for your design. 1. Fro screen 2. Suggested and Worlcup are the 2 categories I can see, you can also add the list of teams in which the user is or the supporting team's list. 2. You can also improve the layout, left white space is creating design gaps and consuming space. horizontal tab which you have used all over is good so please maintain consistency. 3. The center play button here is not going with the interface and interaction, maybe you can use some other icon there. Like on the play button I expect to play something, but I get a screen here. So that's not correct as interaction. 4. Also, you can maintain consistency for icons, currently, I can see filled and lined both. It's difficult to understand other icons in terms of thier use case except home one. Icons are not clear enough in terms of their meanings 5. At top of the screens, all tabs, Top events, world cup, and NBA, have icons, as NBA has colored, WorldCup has white, and top events has no icons. So please maintain consistent standards. 6. For the notification bell icon on black, and blue lined icons maybe you can add a background or broder to it to enhance the visibility of line icons. What tabs Originals, next to featured and what purpose it serves, is not understood to me. 7. At the home screen, you can add the live or upcoming matches for which the user is supporting, or other match highlights, since currently, I can just see news there, so that's providing partial information. Can add some more information to the home screen. 8. Also, a match score table or past sequel playoff details in form of a table will serve as great information to the user 9. Placement of icons at the topbar over streams and Articles, very closely spaced can interrupt user interaction. Also, I Can find them appropriacy there maybe you can provide it somewhere static to the screen or directly on the screen, as this screen is not directly connected to navigation and the internal screen need a back button to trace back.

Really clean design! Just a consideration, did you use the play button as a page in the status bar right? As a user I'd feel a bit confused because usually with a button like that i'm already expect to play a video or something. Let me know what do you think about :)

Awesome color pallette. The interface looks friendly and well thought off. Best of luck.

Good design Awsome

Awesome! Designs looks clean and modern.

Hey Vatsal, Nice thought to show vending panel, but this panel makes the layout bit cluttered, Just giving you a thought.... what about adding on some more details about vending machines there and remove the vending layout, you can add tab there and show information or view of panel, since that vertical rectangular blue patch disturbing layout and making it look dull using space!! You can add details about each machine earnings, when the machine was last filled and other important updates for user!! Just suggesting you, what if you incorporate refilling of multiple products all at once giving a control right there, Like what you have done here is increasing the number of clicks for each slot user has to do things multiple times. Just giving you a thought!! Since you are dealing with large data, what if you incorporate a filter there which would filter on each attribute, just trying to make work of user easier. what's saty? Also giving color Red, Yellow is fine but you have chose blue, which doesn't go with the meaning and action. I mean!! I would suggest you rather use same color whether the solt is partially filled or less, but after all our goal is to keep machine full right? I would recommend you to add a label there if you consider accessibility few of them are color deficient, adding an text or label along with color would help them even more!!! Just Trying make Design accessible to all hope you got my point!!! Keep up the best work!!

Hey @Arun Kumar, the last screen was forgotten to put while creating link in canva, so I added it later. I have put the label to ignore it for challenge to be fair and transparent, viewers can still see it as a part of solution. Thank you!😄

Hey @Siddhida B The opacity is reduced because the machine is not on right now. you can see a toggle switch for the same. But now that you have pointed out I think opacity could be increased for better view. There are sorting options and search bars when more machines are available. There are multiple kind of machines and the challenge was open ended. I have created this UI for regular capacity vending machines. Also the vending machine view can be closed as you can see in 5th screen. Thank you for your feedback!

Thank you @Bharath Modi

Thank you @Nilesh Kumar

Hey, The vending machine layout you presented seems pretty cool, like to address few things here, You have shown deactivated card there 7th card where completely reduced the opacity, it made me difficult to read the content over that card, I hope there might me some reason behind this, but user may miss the important information which he may actually need to be taken in to notice. What about when there are more vending machines available?, do you think these cards would not be best fit for of finding or displaying the massive information. Also when you have thought of presenting products into vending machine format, there are few vending machine capacity of 100s of units. So do you think that layout will actually work there? I was bit distracted by that view, but I am bit confused how are you going to present the larger one? That's all from my side! Best luck.

Congratulations& kudos to you , Vatsal! for a fantastic solution! I can clearly see all aspects of stock management, replenishment, and revenue analysis. I like how you define the actual layout of the vend machine and the tray id for moving or displacing the stock in the machine. Overall, this is a very clean, consistent, and to-the-point solution! Cheers Bharath

Amazing !!!

Checkout this link for better view: https://www.canva.com/design/DAFT6SI3wzM/ZxMApqqZDoJCZkj1t9EE1g/view?utm_content=DAFT6SI3wzM&utm_campaign=designshare&utm_medium=link2&utm_source=sharebutton

Hey Ritik, I would like to give you a few suggestions: Splash/landing screen: - The logo has very thin line because of which it is getting mergered with background which has gradient. Try to use thicker border line and colours with higher contrast. - The text "when you've..." also has low contrast and has very low readability. Try to use colour that have better contrast. - What is does line with dots at the edge stand for, it is not conveying any meaning. Avoid using elements that are not required, additional elements distract the focus from main information. There is no font hierarchy headings and text under it have same font size and font weight. Home screen: - There is a lot of information about a single machine given on the home screen. Only important information like Machine ID, Location and how many product are short in total information can be sufficient. - Why is filter hanging in the middle? Fonts used are larger than the heading at the bottom. It is the first thing that I see when I land on this screen. It is not the primary feature. It should be moved to right edge and font size and weight both can be reduced. - I cannot see any details of how many products each are missing. That is a very critical information that you have missed. - Why is the first machine highlighted with orange patch in the background? It is grabbing more focus. Is there any reason? Hamburger menu: - Try to left align Espresso love with Profile, Settings etc. and reduce the font weight. Machine details: - The information shown here is almost the same except the longer of products than the home screen. More details like revenue earned. How many products in total is the machine short, how to edit the machine and products details and how to refill products. Adding all those information would have made much more sense.

Thank you so much for the feedback Neha. Wonderful suggestions there, love your observant personality. Would love to implement these in the following iterations. PS: When the user clicks on any of the ham menus, they would come back through the back button (named Home), just like it's on the Machine Details page. Machine ID is necessary for the backend to implement the search function. Have an amazing week to you too. :)

Thankyou Purvi. ☃️

Thanks Nilesh bhai. 😊

Thankyou Reeshi Di. Coffee and conversations it is. ❄️🖤

Thankyou so much Hamzah bhaiya. 🖤

Thankyou Fazil bhai, love the feedback. 🖤

Hehe, Thanks Abhinav bhai. 🖤

Thankyou Pranav bhai. Love the feedback. Yes, would love to see your designs as well. 🖤

Thanks Faisal bhai. 🖤

Thankyou Divya. 🖤

Thankyou Raj. Yes, would definitely be working on more. 🖤

Shukriya Harman Paaji. 🖤

Thankyou Piyush Bhai. 🖤

Thankyou Sarthak. 🖤

Hey Ritik, it's a very neat design you've got there. I have some suggestions that you could think of... 1. As I see you have laid info about all machines one after the other and essentially the person will have to look through the whole list to see what needs to be updated. And that red warning sign does make it very easy to scan the list (that's a plus point). Here's another approach, keeping the main goal in mind, why not make a list where in they can first see how many machines need a refill. with less details. e.g. a list with location name and then a sign or number that tells them if any products need a refill. That way it would be easier to scan. Because you see at first glance, I don't "need" to see the zipcode or machine ID of the machine, that information is relevant to me once I know if it needs attention or not. 2. You have a lot of pages in the hamburger menu, but where in all those is the way to get back to the home screen. Like if I click on Profile, how will I come back to home screen. 3. I guess you can better utilise the home screen to make the user's job easier and to show the system's state. For example, you can show "✓ All machines are fully stocked" and "3 machines need refill, see more info" and that way you can give them a sorted list. 4. Lastly, did you consider changing the point of view to the products rather than the machine. I don't know about the research but that's just another perspective to look at. Meaning that you show them which products need refilling in diff areas/machines. Just an idea. I guess that'd be it from my side, hope this helps and have a great week ahead.

Amazing

Amazing!!

The app's clarity and aesthetics are its USP. The name is uniquely mesmerizing and the color gradients are giving a fine caffeine touch as well . Looks like the creator is a connoisseur of consuming conversations and caffeine. Thereby , proving it's reason for creation in its look. A lot of intricate effort has been gone to the design and it is clearly evident from the overall final look. Good luck to the creator !! Hoping to see you win . - An ardent caffeine enthusiast. 💟

Clean and pretty at the same time ✨

Love the app's Idea its sounds useful. While it comes to the design of the app its too eye catching and looks unique too . I like how simple the colors are . Overall superb work . excellently done !!

It's soo good ✨

simple yet attractive !!! radial color gradient really goes well with the homepage design. Can see how much thought had to put in logo creation. App name sound so surreal Espresso love. lesssgoo . P.S: Also thanks for notifying me about this app i'll be uploading few of my ideas here for sure.

Minimal and beautiful.

Beautiful.

Its very very noice . Hope to see more of these .

This is the Figma Link through which you can see all the screens. https://www.figma.com/file/HmBMxi18e6EMAxzWkh6HSP/Ritik-Balwant-Espresso-Love?node-id=0%3A1&t=FquJSZoHY03AYRPX-1

love the color palette

Nice Design

Hey Vatsal, cool design. I was also thinking of adding a mouse zoom feature, but was running out of time. I just had a few things I'd like to point out here, and a few suggestions. 1. The record button (top-left screen) I guess could be red color (as is the norm to spot a record button) Familiarity to other products helps, don't you think? 2. In the second screen (top right) I'm guessing the big round button in the middle signifies that recording is in progress but in that case, user could use a timer. Also, as is the behavior in all camera apps, the button that's used to start recording also ends it. But in the screen that is placed separate. So I wonder what's the purpose of the red circular button in the center? Also, if the recording is going on it'd help to see a separate toolbar that doesn't show options that I might not need. Like I don't see myself changing the screen ratio once I start recording. Maybe that's something to consider. I hope this helps. Other than this the app looks great, clean and minimal. You've done a great job here. Kudos.

I agree with Neha there. These screens don't look much consistent to me, with no design theme going on. Also, the image you posted doesn't show the features of the app clearly as it is quite zoomed out. I hope you improve these things in further designs.

Extraordinary

Nice one

Jaabruu

Khare khar 1k number hon lala

Nice one

Nice job

Ek number

Ha moj haaa

Nice work 🙌

Hey Bhavik, Good approach for great user experience and useful UI

Nice design. Keep it up 👍

Good work. Keep it up

Nice design keep it up👍

Nice Design 👍

Hey Bhavik, correct me if I'm wrong, but it looks like the screens are mere screenshots from some other app (except the screen on bottom left) Because all the other screens don't quite match the style of the bottom-left one. That's just an observation, I could be wrong. But maybe you could try designing with a consistent theme. I hope this helps. Have a great day.

No, Vatsal, If you had taken inspiration from existing apps and provided a solution after modifying their designs then it would be better. But here it looks like you have copied others' work and modified their designs. Modifying "Existing apps" and "others work" is a huge difference. Please try to understand. And Crowwwnn is a UX design challenge for all the designers who can practice design here (using their own creativity)and provide a solution.

I would like to clarify some things here. Yes, I have taken inspiration from the link shared by Sushrita. What I got "Inspired" from - Tab in Second screen, which is the most common flow across apps to select image/s. -- Bottom navigation in fourth screen (which has some added features so NOT COPIED but improved) -Bottom drawer - Colors: White and grey - Top navigation: Back button😂 and undo/redo (only if you have not done competitive analysis of "pretty makeup app, You cam perfect app") Things which are "Original" -The link which is claimed to be copied is about hair color and NOT hair cuts/styles. - Scanning process. -Tags of original when there is no makeover applied. -Using images of single model with different hairstyles. For some of them I have used photoshop to show the results. (Which I feel is the most important thing to clearly communicate my design to viewers and jury) -UX writing -Makeover for male as a feature which has beard shapes, beard color, hair style, hair color and looks. For those who think flow is copied, I hope you know something about competitive analysis. You might as well check other apps I took inspiration from. It is important to learn and apply best features from existing apps to reduce time, efforts and money and most importantly provide best user experience. God bless!

From my experience, the UI along with the logic behind it, flows and the usability is how the judgement is done for Crowwwn challenges. So I know where you are coming from @sushrita. This in my opinion too is heavily copied from the link which you have shared. Great that you pointed out 👏🏼

Hey, Siana! This is not called taking inspiration from others' work. He copied the whole layout and changed some content. Could you please check this design https://dribbble.com/shots/17189410-DIOR-AR-Makeup-Real-Time-virtual-Makeup-Experience? And tell me from where do you think he has taken this design as inspiration? That's all you have to give a solution then why is everyone working so hard to show their creativity? Everyone can copy what's the big deal about that. The main thing is you have to apply your own creativity and provide a good solution here. Ya ya, sure he has done well by copying others' work. I just gave feedback. let the judge decide :)

@Sushrita Kumari Padhy I think you went far with your feedback this time. Taking inspiration from UI and copying other's work has a vast difference. This platform is about providing right solution and Vatsal has done that clearly among all the participants including you. Almost every one has provided images which are not up to the mark except this one which speaks a lot about his work. Try to provide constructive criticism as most of the points in your feedback does not make sense too.

Good job Vatsal! The flow is simple, easy to understand and serves the right solution to problem.

Hey, Vatsal! Why did you copy others' work? If you had to copy then why did you participate? Please present your own work. -Home screen- ->You have kept the "try now" button then why did you keep the camera button there in the nav bar? What is that for? ->Make sure all icon should be consistent. ->The scanning tag and the original tag should have been two different colors. -> As you have shown hairstyles for females you should have kept in mind that so many hairstyles, hair colors, and their shades are there. Users can't swipe to see all the styles and colors know. If you could add a filter for them then that would be easy for the user and will also save time. -> If the user wants to try different shades of color then how will she do it? -> On the last screen, you have shown both the hair color option and hairstyle option separately for men. Why are that options not on the 4th screen? You just put a hairs options only. Please do proper research and brainstorm about these small things. -> I have noticed on the last two screens, three white circles and one white square are there at the back of the "prev and next" buttons. Why is that not on the other 3 screens? Thanks!!

Hey @Jorge Santos, thanks mate! Glad you like it.

Hi @Dhananjay Chopra That is export button. The image can be saved and/or shared for reference or to take reviews on the style!

I liked this approach, very complete and simple!

Hi Vatsal Can you tell me what is the function of the top right corner button in the style selection screen?

Hi Vaishnavi, I have some queries to raise!! 1. In the concept we are using the ideal user/model given the scanning AI would have the understanding of differentiating head from face, so i believe that can be sorted. 😧 2. In terms of flow, you can follow the quick walkthrough I have shared above, in the future will make sure to present designs with flow marks and in order. 3. Surely can be worked, the floating items are suggestive options. 4. Once the user has used the hairstyles, he may get the related products prompting the user to use the product that is required or use a map to visit the desired saloon/stylist that can give you the hairstyle you need. 5. The visit shop - is suggestive but not compulsory. 6. I agree, some improvements are required. 7. The map appears once the user has finalized a hairstyle and hits the visit shop. 8. The text implies "scan your hair to get perfect recommendations - a default instruction.". Thank you for your remarks and feedback 👍 Surely opens up a new front for ideas and points noted to be focused on in the future. Many thanks!!

Hey, Core UX I have some queries to raise!! 1. You have given hair scanning, I a worried if a person is Bald, how are you going to scan????? 😧 2. The design style is too abstract, the elements used here are having drastic contrast colors and shapes which difficult to find the action elements. 3. Also, important controls are Camouflaged on the screen due to inconsistent shapes and styles. 4. Hairstyle and product tabs are next to each other, is there any logic behind that please justify. 5. The visit shop - is merged in the image "9th screen". 6. It's difficult to understand the possible affordances for a few components, like Apply filter component on the home page. 7. Search is surrounded by a map, usability wise please fix this. one may hit the map by mistake with an intention of search. 8. Some random text added over 1st screen is not legible. You have really added great effort on the whole!!! 👍 but, usability wise above points can be worked upon. Hope this helps!!

This looks like an innovative product. I see the utility of it for people from the beauty industry. It'd be great to see how it recommends looks based on different face types. All in all looks sleek and has great potential.

@jS Designs The conceptual flow allows the user to; 1. Scan the hairs, 2. Choose hairstyles from the library 3. Apply color, and adjust features. 4. Share or stream to get feedback, 5. Get AI-based recommendations on hair care, products beauty salons, and hair-care centers through the map.

Hi, I believe the first image is original. Then in second screen how the hair has different color? In the 8th screen I see hair color option, where did this come from? User flow is quite confusing me. When style tab is selected, it looks like product tab is active and vice versa. You have shown the functionality of hair cut but it would have been great if you had shown girl with different haircut through AI too. Showing likes and comments on image that is yet to get makeover doesn't make sense! Bottom navigation is missing. It can give clarity and easiness to your flow. Overall I loved the image selection and UI!

Modi-hair is one of the unique feature that will help everyone to identify weather the hairstyle would fit on to the person or not. This app will be beneficial for every individual including hairdressers, salons and me as well.

This website is superb 😍 and really its very superior

Very clean and unique modern UI design 🔥

Bhavik, sorry to say but there are just many Red flags about this design, just take them as feedback to improve. Let's start with your description. 1. Failed with font selection. Using a font like Playfair display for the body & paragraph isn't a good practice. They are legible for Title/Headings but not for body text. 2. You have opted to go with a Dark theme, but the splash screen does have user interaction and that screen is light. Imagine a user clicking on the Entry button and suddenly the screen will change to Dark mode, that's not correct. To me it seems like an Intro screen, not a Splash screen, splash screens are usually some transitions or smooth animations. Why should we add an extra step at the cost of an extra button (Entry button) if it's not needed, on a splash screen? 3. Splash/Intro Screen and Gender screen body texts are of different sizes, be consistent with that. It seems female & male buttons should be a bit smaller. 4. Now things going a bit crazy here, the illustrations are very good but the page is wrong, imagine the user is 35-45 years old, and how he/she would perceive seeing cartoons instead of a real human face or his/her face. The page doesn't even have any color-selecting feature, which is a basic requirement. See according to psychology humans trust real pictures more than illustrations. According to me, you should add another page simply by taking a picture of the user with some guidelines, and then on this page, overlay the hairstyles over her head with a Before-After toggle. There should be a hair color selector, a hairstyle selector, a save button (if you're adding account options, and if not then to gallery) & a share button. 5. Bottom Navigation bar is again a red flag, this app is not very popular, so from starting you need to add icons & texts below them. And also I haven't seen good apps using a floating Bottom Nav bar. 6. There's a search option on the Top of the Near By Salon screen and also on the bottom nav bar. Confusing. This page is also not following the Dark theme perfectly, Too bright on the top section. You've added nearby saloon cards, I don't know if that is realistic or not, but the minimum price and distance from your location are missing from the cards. The card Heading and Subheading texts are so big, I doubt if a big name fits in there. 7. "Choose your gender" Title is placed in a near to perfect place. But what about Hairstyle and Nearby Saloon page? Consistency is the key. In the nearby salon page, There's no need to place the page title/app bar there at the cost of some extra white space at the top. White space is good when used properly. But here we can give more real estate to the saloon list by placing the app bar at the perfect place. Just take them as feedback.

Extremely high quality design and very clean and unique modern UI design 🔥

Hi Bhavika, What if I like the first haircut option and second haircolor? There should be different functionality to select haircolor and hairstyle. 3D characters look very different from real humans and selecting a style on the basis of 3D character might or might not look good on actual human. Your app looks more like bitmoji/memoji. Stylist at salon cannot choose hair color/style on the basis of it.

design concept and idea just awesome and clean deisgn

Wonderful design and very much user friendly

Great work 🤗

Great 👍 Superb design..

Very good design

That's great

Great choice of colors, Good Job🔥🙌🏻

Very good work. Very clean and modern UI.

The design is very and accurate. Here your hard work can be seen. Looking for such amazing designs. 🔥👍

An extremely user-friendly design, with all necessary features at hand 🙌🏻

HeyAviral. Here is my feedback on your design- Why there are bookmark and share on add project screen.…..they don’t add sense there. Again you as per your design I could not comprehend the screen linking. How should I cancel from wizard there’s just way to step back. Verification of id and business doc, is also step included in publishing project that need to be highlighted. Hope it helps.

Hi Shreya, thank you for your feedback! Your suggestion is duly noted :)

Exceptional work! I love that you've focused on UX, keeping the UI minimal! The design covers both the investee and the investor side of things. I see a lot of UX laws applied. Quick overview, hierarchy, and confirmation messages. Smaller details like bookmark button, use of tags, enable and disable states. My only suggestion is to add a confirmation window before making an investment or submitting a project.

Hey Hasan ! You have great UI skills. The color scheme and hierarchy is eye pleasing. Good Job ! You created this design from the investor's perspective, which is also an important part, but the core challenge What I understand is " invest in my idea in exchange for equity " Now the challenge here is what would be the value of equity? Because people are investing in Ideas, not in startups. What you think about this ? BTW keep it up !!

1. Crowdfunding as domain is really vast.. there are lot of details related to campaigns like story pitching format, other detail verification of business owner ID, and bank verification, setting up equity reward etc. each step has too be verified and evaluated before the final launch. Content pitching is the key for such interfaces after all your idea should build a trust and attract more investors. 2. So you should abide your solution with respect to problem statement adding other details and task flow for the campaign creation. 3. How your content is seen and affecting investor responses for that previewing campaign appearance before launch is must.. 4. These are data driven interactions need to be carefully handled and are more feasible over larger displays. - Hope this helps in improvisation. 👍

To me, this is just so great, you did more than what was asked for in the challenge, but yet you nailed it!

Hey Sushrita, Color scheme is pretty balanced and the hierarchy of information is organized. overall Ui is great. You come up with the solution and you also put up many other aspect like charity, volunteer and Donate. you done an amazing job but now this is more of social service app rather then the startup crowdfunding. it's more look like "Donating in startup Idea" rather then "Investing in startup Idea" There is no detail and system about exchange equity so the main challenge still unresolved.

Hi Sushrita, Thank you for contributing such a well-intentioned and public service oriented app! What a unique way to bring the stem of the prompt into something public/philanthropic and utility based towards crowdfunding. The details, the stories, the profiles and organization of the overall app is amazing. I love this idea and is so well mapped out. I would also add as an area of potential improvement is something that would have been very difficult to do - a real option of equity in something somewhere. The gift cards/heart exchange is a great option, and is more like a membership reward system, so I think to fully address the prompt it could have included perhaps stock in certain charity if one were to reach a certain number of donation - or something perhaps along those lines (truthfully, I am also not fully sure how that could be possible here - but if you have thought of this fact and could not find a solution please let me know/respond). Aside form that point, really its tough to provide anything other than positive feedback for this one. Great job!

Hey! Sushrita You put a great deal of effort on both usability and aesthetics. After comprehending the fundamental of the Problem Statement, I would advise adding something to the exchange for investment in the idea, such as equity, debt, a pool option, etc. If I'm wrong, kindly correct me. I also would appreciate your opinions. Thanks & Regards Bharath

Great work Vatsal! Though it's inspired from something marvelous but you executed very well with great care of usability in mind. i would appreciate your feedback on my submission! Cheers Bharat

Hey, Vatsal I must say your design is cool. I just saw Nickelfox's UI design in the Figma community. Their UI structure and your UI Structure are very similar such as spaces and icons. You modified some elements. Still, you couldn't do that properly. But you didn't copy everything. That's good. UI POV -> Focus on padding. -> Improve Legibility. -> Heading could be bigger. -> Use soft shadows. -> All Icons should be consistent. Make sure they all share the same weight. In the nav bar, you have used a filled battery icon and you have kept outlined battery icon in the charging station section. There are blue colors on both sides so more focus is going on that part only. Use some dark colors instead of blue. ->Battery icon should be above the heading. ->Ideally, you should put two sentences in your modal. Having a clear message, Users will understand what message you’re trying to tell them and possible actions. -> The headline and the CTA are usually the two most important elements of your popups, so make sure they have enough contrast. Here, you had to change the navigation button color. On the third screen, why is that 30804 there? And Battery rang bar is different from other range bars. I think something seems wrong with the third screen. Thank you.

It's very good design and appreciable...

Can be improvised - 1- On the home screen:- - WidgetUI for the nearby charging stations on the home screen can be improved: looks too empty. - Focus on the remaining battery life of 62% is less due to visuals, for the user remaining battery life should be clearly visible and highlighted since it is important 2-The timing widget "full charge in" on the home screen currently in HH:MM: SS format is shown in the design, this fits well for the current 00:30:25, kerning changes with changes in numbers so the widget should be flexible enough to equip data. 3- Usability wise Bookmark and Search icon with transparent background on the map is not that feasible. Should have some clickable area. 4- Only one widget "Charging info" has an image added what if that numeric value increase is that widget flexible enough? 5- Also, the navigation back button could be provided on top, either keeping the screen title at the center or left aligned. Done well - The UI looks Cool but usability wise few things have to be worked upon. Use of font sizes, weights, and spacing all over is maintained correctly and consistently 👍, Like the logo Charge X. there is a lot in the feedback other than spacing, and typos, that I tried to highlight as per the usability Hope this helps 😊

Great work Meet ! i would appreciate if you have any Feedback on my submission as well!.

Hey, Sushrita Kumari Padhy , Thank You for your feedback, here I want to clear up some points. -> Yes, I designed for Mercedes Benz and the app name should not be Mercedes Benz! that’s why I named it to ChargEx. -> Reason behind putting a charging station on the homepage is when users see their battery percentage on the home page he/she can easily note the map feature so that in one click they can find out nearby stations. Actually, it will redirect to the map page. -> charging bar shows the current battery percentage and battery health is showing the condition of the battery. both are different, this data is connected with the battery expiry so if battery health is under 10-20% so that changing date is near. -> I checked this design on my phone and the font and icons were clearly visible maybe this presentation seemed smaller but actually I followed all guidelines of typography and icon rules. ->that is not a 3d icon in charging info. it is the picture of a charger that is supported in a specific car. each car supported different kinds of charger cables and ports so visually it’ll be more clear to users which charger should they use for their car.

Hey, Meet I must say your design concept is nice. Here is my feedback on your submission: On the welcome page, why did you name that ChargeX? You have designed interfaces for Mercedes Benz, right? On the home page, instead of showing charging stations try something different. On the battery analysis page, the charging bar and battery health both are the same meaning. You have shown the charging state on the home page again you have shown that on the battery analysis page differently. You could have shown a different state. Make your design consistent. UI POV -> If you are using the status bar then have to use the bottom home indicator too. Otherwise don't use it. -Home page- ->It's not required to show a map icon right to the charging stations. -> Battery range and full charge Icons could be bigger. -Battery analysis- ->I didn't get it. Why did you split the elements here? Could you please clarify? ->Text size could be bigger. ->Focus on typos. Some texts are small and some are big. ->You can use Figma mirror/sketch mirror/crystal/ adobe xd for previewing the designs. There you will see the UI mistakes. -> Use the Battery icon instead of the charge/volt icon. Icons need to be recognizable. ->Improve legibility by increasing element spacing. ->Why did you put the 3D Icon in the charging info? -Nearby Stations- -> Why that 2.5km text weight is low? Don't you find that important? ->Elements/cards could be lit bigger. Not able to see those texts. Even users will be frustrated by seeing this. For better readability show one or two cards/elements that's enough. Thank you.

An extremely user-friendly design, with all necessary features at hand 🙌🏻

The design is very and accurate. Here your hard work can be seen. Looking for such amazing designs

I like the way the UI looks and how easy to use this kind of features in an app Good work👍🏻

Hey Meet, The design and colours are outstanding. On the 4th screen, the nearby station page can have a "location icon" rather than a "message icon".

Creative!!!!✨

Amazing Design, Great work💫👍

Amazing work🤩🤩🤩

Awesome and pixel perfect design meet. Like your work.

Hello @aishwarya, thanks for the feedback. I noted your point but the ideology behind the using this app module is before you use your car you'll be notify in advance

Seems great design 👍

Great page designs, I think showing similar information in dashboard designs will be helpful. Liked the idea of how information is showing in the app but I think app information is the least usable but same visualisation in the dashboard will help more.

Great

Fantastic design really love it

Can be improvised -> Dashboard screen: text over illustration is less readable. Elements are to closely placed which affects readability and makes the screen too crowdy. ->Use of Text and visuals is not balanced on the overall layout. Too loud visuals on a dark theme ->Consistency with CTA/ colors and contrast is disturbed for eg. Pairing screen, car information screen ->You need to work on text color content and overall legibility ->Most crucial information for battery on the dashboard - Battery 80% what is that battery status, and range? ->Need meaningful labels also below that use to have the label "range" so what does this information about - remaining distance estimate or covered by car till now? if so, please mention that properly After all it's important for the user. ->On the onboarding screen: Some generic heading -- What does generic heading mean? Can you add sensible information??? ->Car information screen: showing car visual on half screen and the half screen has information this can be changed to full width removing full visual. since information/data can be random and not fixed with a fixed length ->Space between the Welcome screen and the Go to the dashboard is extremely. ->Showing car charging history on the home screen doesn't make any sense. ->Green center icon looks weird even if the active tab is home, this green icon grabs all attention even if the tab is not active. _________________________ Feedback over selecting form factor: > For most crucial information and analytical data about car health, one has to switch to a mobile or larger display. so do you think interaction overwatch is apt? what about finding and replacing the battery that's requiring interaction, to see all battery details and stations (information about the station, pricing, etc ) overwatch? All analytical and important information needs a larger display than a watch. So over this switch of the device from watch to mobile do you think one can manage all the controls simultaneously while DRIVING or WITHOUT DRIVING? There is a lot to add to the feedback from my perspective, but I kept it simple and explanatory, hope this helps :)

I forgot to add something -> It doesn't seem necessary to show those tags there. Those tags could have been a bit smaller. You could use the "#" symbol for better understanding.

Hey, I must say your design is amazing😃. I really liked the colors you chose. Here is my feedback on your submission: You could have tried different icons for comments. All White Spaces should be consistent. Shadows are not visible on the profile page. Give more value to them. It looks like all are one question/post. ->There is a lot of space between the forms and the button on the Sign in & sign up page. -> Recovery password is a link button now so why that is different from other link buttons? -> Add lines between the posts and try some different tags like pinned, trending, etc. -> You have kept the show menu icon horizontal somewhere & vertical somewhere -> If you have given the Read More link button then you have to write the less link button too. ->You should have shown an in-active state for upvote and downvote. How can we see if we don't vote then how will that upvote/downvote button look? Upvote and Downvote Buttons could be a little bigger. ->Remove the stroke from the profile avatar. It Looks odd. ->All Icons should be consistent. To keep things consistent, make sure they all share the same weight and are either filled or outlined. Thanks.

~From Ux perspective your solution justifies users requirement and problem statement. ~Feature for boosting questions responses is value added also feature to - Save as draft is useful. ~I really like the decent color tones used overall good approach and thought process. ~like the flash screen design🙂

Great

Well, I would say, white text over the blue gradient is not clearly visible. The rating part for questions is not needed rather this can be shown for answers you can show the comment count, upvote count, and other actions. Again prominent action CTA is needed, like adding a photo or attaching a file rest of the button is not readable. The answers screen it’s too confusing, whether it’s answers to questions given by the user or answers to questions raised by the user. Need a proper title. Can add some more screenshot or figmalink

Excellent

Awesome